An Historic Review of Art Commerce and Craftsmanship by Harry Davis gives a historical look at the words Art and Craft. For me it was a foundational essay. Essentially the two words began as meaning the same thing but where ‘Art’ was Anglo Saxon, ‘Craft’ was Slav. The Anglo Saxons ran things and had money. The Slavs did not have as much money. The Medicies in Florence elevated Painting Sculpture and Architecture by relieving them of the constraints of the guild system and moved them into the academy thereby elevating their apparent status. They became known as Arts. Stone carving became split, hard stone sculpture was art, soft stones such as limestone was called craft. Metalwork was spit by the value of the metal. Gold and silver workers became artisans, Lead, Copper, Tin, became craftsman or smiths.
Katz’ Equation, Craft+$$= Art
(f I was writing a longer essay I would talk about the word “value” which we increasingly confuse with “values” here.)
I believe that any and everything we make is somehow expressive. We cannot help but walk, talk, eat and write expressively. Given a lump of clay and being told to squeeze it we do not all do it the same. How we do it is expressive of who we are. We inflict our meaning onto our production regardless of intent.
Katz’ Definition, Any artifact of intelligence is expressive.
One of the aspects of all of this that we need to detangle, in order to understand ourselves is that we confuse the maker and the appreciator.
Appreciation of an object in this sense is the act of looking at an object and finding meaning. This really is a different act than the act of making. We can appreciate, find meaning, in the natural object as well as the made object. The meaning we find, the meaning we discover, does not need to be meaning imparted on the object by its maker. It is assigned to the object by the appreciator (oddly an under appreciated part of the art world). Appreciation raises the value of an object. Related here is The Book of Gifts,, there are a couple. I have to find out which but can’t do it while I am writing without breaking the organization and line of thought.
To Appreciate is to raise its abstract value, but like with Craft and Art, and Value and Values we get monetary value mixed in. Monetary value is abstract. Real value is more concrete. This needs an essay too.
- The Book of Gifts, The Gift ( I am unsure, I lent my copy to a student) I will edit this if I figure out which of the books with this title.
- The Harry Davis article I think was published in Ceramics Monthly between 1976 and 1985